The MMO landscape has been evolving rapidly, but traditional MMORPGs have become a rare sight. In any given year, we are lucky if we see the release of even one new game that harkens back to the classic style of MMOs that many gamers fell in love with years ago. The genre’s devoted fanbase eagerly awaits these releases, hoping for new experiences that capture the magic of the old while bringing fresh innovations.
“Throne and Liberty” is one such game that has recently made waves in the MMO community. Developed by NCSoft, this game promised to deliver a vast, immersive world filled with adventures, beautiful landscapes, and intricate gameplay mechanics. Given the scarcity of traditional MMOs, the launch of “Throne and Liberty” was a significant event, attracting attention from gamers worldwide.
The development of “Throne and Liberty” has been a long journey, marked by numerous updates and changes based on player feedback. From its initial announcement to the recent launch in South Korea, the game has shown great promise. However, like any major release, it has faced its share of challenges and controversies.
The Promise of “Throne and Liberty”
“Throne and Liberty” captured the attention of MMO enthusiasts with its ambitious scope and innovative features. The game promised a massive open world, filled with dynamic events, large-scale non-instanced dungeons, and varied PvP activities. Its visual appeal, boasting extensive draw distances and diverse biomes, made exploration an exciting prospect. Furthermore, the technical performance was solid, ensuring a smooth and immersive gameplay experience.
NCSoft’s commitment to listening to player feedback during the beta phase led to significant improvements before the official release. The combat system, initially criticized for its static nature, was revamped to be more dynamic and fluid, aligning with modern tab-target MMOs. The removal of the autoplay feature “astral hunting” and the adjustment of progression speeds to reward active play were also welcomed changes. These updates contributed to a strong foundation, garnering positive initial reactions.
However, the game’s potential was tempered by the emergence of several critical issues as players delved deeper into its mechanics. While the core features and content were praised, underlying problems, particularly related to monetization and botting, began to surface. These challenges would significantly impact the game’s long-term reception and success.
Try my AI Tabletop generators...
or LOOT my Roguelike novel for free right now!
Early Reception and Launch in South Korea
When “Throne and Liberty” launched in South Korea, it was met with a wave of anticipation. The early reception was generally positive, with players praising the game for its ambitious scope and innovative features. NCSoft succeeded in creating a massive open world that could host thousands of players on a single server without the typical phasing issues. This allowed for a more immersive experience where hundreds of players could be seen interacting in the same area.
Key Features and Visual Appeal
One of the standout features of “Throne and Liberty” is its expansive open world. The game includes a variety of activities such as open-world public events, large-scale non-instanced dungeons, solo challenge towers, world bosses, and open-world PvP. The visual presentation of the game is equally impressive, featuring a significant draw distance, a wide array of biomes, and numerous traversal options, making exploration both exciting and visually rewarding. Additionally, the game performs well technically, ensuring a smooth gameplay experience.
Positive Aspects of the Korean Release
The positive reception in South Korea was also due to several key improvements made from the game’s beta phase. The combat system, which was previously criticized for being static, was overhauled to be more dynamic and fluid. This change brought the combat mechanics more in line with modern tab-target MMOs, allowing players to move while performing basic attacks and utilize skills with built-in movement. Furthermore, NCSoft removed the controversial autoplay feature known as “astral hunting,” which allowed the game to play itself while the player was AFK. This change, along with adjustments to the progression system, ensured that active play was rewarded, enhancing the overall game experience.
Endgame Issues and Pay-to-Win Concerns
As players advanced into the endgame of “Throne and Liberty,” several significant issues became apparent. The most glaring problem was the emergence of pay-to-win mechanics, which created a disparity between players who spent real money and those who did not. This imbalance affected the game’s competitive aspects, particularly in PvP and guild rankings, leading to frustration among the community.
The core of the pay-to-win concerns revolved around gear progression, skill enhancement, and dungeon runs. Players could purchase growth stones and other items needed for upgrading gear through the cash shop, accelerating their progress significantly compared to those who relied solely on in-game efforts. This created a scenario where financial investment became a shortcut to power, undermining the game’s integrity and fairness.
Community reaction to these pay-to-win mechanics was mixed. While some appreciated the convenience of progressing faster by spending money, many others felt it detracted from the game’s competitive balance and overall enjoyment. This division highlighted the challenge for NCSoft in maintaining a fair and engaging environment for all players, regardless of their financial contributions.
Emergence of Pay-to-Win Mechanics
As players delved deeper into “Throne and Liberty,” particularly into the endgame content, several concerning issues began to surface. Chief among these was the emergence of pay-to-win mechanics. The power progression system, particularly through gear and skill enhancements, became heavily tied to the game’s monetization strategy. Players discovered that progressing through the game efficiently required either an immense amount of time or spending real money.
Detailed Explanation of Pay-to-Win Elements
The game’s gear progression involves leveling up items using “growth stones,” which can be earned through gameplay or purchased with real money. This dual system of acquisition created a significant advantage for players willing to spend money. Similarly, the trait system for enchanting gear required multiple versions of the same item, obtainable through both in-game farming and the auction house, which uses the game’s premium currency, Lucent, purchasable with real money.
Daily dungeon runs, another crucial component of gear progression, were limited by dungeon tokens. Players received a set number of tokens per day, which allowed for a finite number of dungeon runs. However, purchasing a “blessing” from the cash shop provided additional tokens, enabling more daily runs and, consequently, faster progression. The progression of skills also followed a similar model, where training books needed for skill upgrades could be acquired through gameplay or bought via the auction house.
Community Reactions and Long-Term Implications
The community’s reaction to these pay-to-win mechanics was predictably mixed. While some players appreciated the ability to expedite their progress through financial investment, many others felt that this system undermined the game’s integrity and fairness. The long-term implications of these mechanics suggested that free-to-play players would struggle to keep up with those willing to spend money, leading to a disparity in power and overall game experience.
Botting and Its Impact on Gameplay
Botting emerged as a major issue in “Throne and Liberty,” significantly affecting the gameplay experience. Bots, which automate farming and other in-game activities, disrupted the economy and created unfair advantages for those using them. The presence of bots led to inflated prices for essential items and a scarcity of resources for legitimate players, further exacerbating the game’s pay-to-win issues.
The impact of botting extended beyond the economy, influencing competitive aspects like guild rankings and PvP. Guilds utilizing bots could maintain higher activity levels and secure top spots in the rankings, gaining access to exclusive rewards. This created a significant disadvantage for guilds that played fairly, undermining the competitive integrity of the game.
Make life as a Gamemaster easier.... If you play Dungeon & Dragons, Pathfinder, or other fantasy tabletop role-playing games, this RPG random tables book is full of encounters, NPCs, and more. Available as an eBook or in a classic print format. Either way, you'll have a wealth of adventure ideas at your fingertips.
Despite efforts to curb botting through bans and other measures, the problem persisted, highlighting a need for more effective anti-cheat mechanisms. The ongoing struggle against bots not only frustrated players but also tarnished the game’s reputation, contributing to a decline in player trust and satisfaction.
Overview of Botting Issues
Another significant issue that plagued “Throne and Liberty” was the rampant use of bots. Bots can negatively impact any MMO by disrupting the in-game economy, occupying farming spots, and tagging quest mobs, which can frustrate legitimate players. In “Throne and Liberty,” the botting problem was particularly severe due to the game’s competitive nature and ranking systems.
How Bots Affect the In-Game Economy and Player Experience
Bots were able to farm materials and currency around the clock, giving bot users a significant advantage in progressing through the game. This constant farming allowed them to flood the market with resources, impacting the economy and making it difficult for regular players to compete. Furthermore, bots contributed to an imbalanced ranking system, where guilds using bots could easily outpace those who did not.
Fantasy RPG AI Generators with ChatGPT+
Make life as a Game Master easier.... If you play Dungeon & Dragons, Pathfinder, or other fantasy tabletop role-playing games, check out my DND AI backstory generator and other fine AI RPG tools at LitRPG Adventures Workshop today.
Specific Problems with the Guild Ranking System
The guild ranking system in “Throne and Liberty” is crucial, as the top guilds gain access to exclusive rewards, including a castle that provides substantial in-game currency. Guilds that employed bots to farm materials and maintain high activity levels were able to dominate the rankings, leaving other guilds at a disadvantage. This imbalance caused frustration among players who felt they could not compete fairly.
Financial Performance and Developer Response
Despite the initial excitement, “Throne and Liberty” did not perform well financially for NCSoft. The company experienced a revenue drop in Q4 2023 compared to the previous year, a period which included the game’s release. Notably, NCSoft did not include “Throne and Liberty” in their detailed earnings breakdown, a first in eight years, indicating the game’s underperformance.
NCSoft acknowledged the game’s shortcomings during their financial reporting, attributing the revenue decline to the game’s poor performance. They emphasized their commitment to addressing the game’s issues and expressed optimism for the upcoming global release. The resignation of the game’s producer also signaled significant internal changes aimed at improving the game’s prospects.
Since the Korean launch, the developers have made several updates to “Throne and Liberty,” addressing some of the pay-to-win concerns and making adjustments based on community feedback. While some pay-to-win elements remain, changes such as requiring gameplay for acquiring tier 2 gear have been positively received. However, the introduction of a pay-to-win subscription model, offering significant in-game advantages, has continued to stir controversy.
NCSoft’s Financial Losses and Lack of Transparency
Despite the initial excitement, “Throne and Liberty” did not perform well financially for NCSoft. The company experienced their revenue drop in Q4 2023 compared to the previous year, a period which included the game’s release. Notably, NCSoft did not include “Throne and Liberty” in their detailed earnings breakdown, a first in eight years, indicating the game’s underperformance.
Developer Admissions and Focus on Global Release
NCSoft acknowledged the game’s shortcomings during their financial reporting, attributing the revenue decline to the game’s poor performance. They emphasized their commitment to addressing the game’s issues and expressed optimism for the upcoming global release. The resignation of the game’s producer also signaled significant internal changes aimed at improving the game’s prospects.
Updates and Community Response
Since the Korean launch, the developers have made several updates to “Throne and Liberty,” addressing some of the pay-to-win concerns and making adjustments based on community feedback. While some pay-to-win elements remain, changes such as requiring gameplay for acquiring tier 2 gear have been positively received. However, the introduction of a pay-to-win subscription model, offering significant in-game advantages, has continued to stir controversy.
Future Prospects and Recommendations for Global Launch
The success of the global launch is crucial not only for NCSoft but also for Amazon, the game’s global publisher. A successful launch could ensure the game’s longevity and potential expansions, including a possible console port. Both companies are likely focused on making necessary changes to avoid the pitfalls experienced during the Korean release.
For “Throne and Liberty” to succeed globally, several key changes are necessary. Firstly, the cash shop needs a significant overhaul or removal, focusing on cosmetic items rather than pay-to-win mechanics. Removing the ability to purchase growth stones, trait extracts, and training books with real money would level the playing field. The game should also eliminate the purchase of additional dungeon runs, relying instead on traditional time-gated farming without financial shortcuts.
Addressing the botting issue is essential. This could involve more stringent detection and banning measures. Additionally, reworking the guild ranking system to reduce the advantage gained through constant farming would help balance the competition. Finding alternative ways to rank guilds that do not incentivize botting could improve the overall fairness and enjoyment of the game.
By implementing these changes, “Throne and Liberty” has the potential to overcome its initial challenges and establish itself as a significant player in the MMO genre. The global launch represents a fresh start, offering an opportunity to build a more balanced and engaging experience for all players.
Importance of a Successful Global Launch
The success of the global launch is crucial not only for NCSoft but also for Amazon, the game’s global publisher. A successful launch could ensure the game’s longevity and potential expansions, including a possible console port. Both companies are likely focused on making necessary changes to avoid the pitfalls experienced during the Korean release.
Make life as a Gamemaster easier.... If you play Dungeon & Dragons, Pathfinder, or other fantasy tabletop role-playing games, this RPG random tables book is full of encounters, NPCs, and more. Available as an eBook or in a classic print format. Either way, you'll have a wealth of adventure ideas at your fingertips.
Key Changes Needed for Success
For “Throne and Liberty” to succeed globally, several key changes are necessary. Firstly, the cash shop needs a significant overhaul or removal, focusing on cosmetic items rather than pay-to-win mechanics. Removing the ability to purchase growth stones, trait extracts, and training books with real money would level the playing field. The game should also eliminate the purchase of additional dungeon runs, relying instead on traditional time-gated farming without financial shortcuts.
Combatting Botting and Reworking Guild Rankings
Addressing the botting issue is essential. This could involve more stringent detection and banning measures. Additionally, reworking the guild ranking system to reduce the advantage gained through constant farming would help balance the competition. Finding alternative ways to rank guilds that do not incentivize botting could improve the overall fairness and enjoyment of the game.
Throne and Liberty MMORPG 2024
“Throne and Liberty” holds significant promise as one of the few traditional MMOs to launch in recent years. While it has faced challenges, particularly with pay-to-win mechanics and botting, there is still hope for its future. With the right adjustments and a successful global launch, “Throne and Liberty” could become a beloved title in the MMO community. Both NCSoft and Amazon have the opportunity to learn from the Korean release and implement changes that will enhance the game’s appeal and longevity. As MMO enthusiasts, we can only hope that “Throne and Liberty” rises to meet its potential and provides a rich, engaging experience for players worldwide.
