Frosthaven Board Game Review: An Icy and Pricey Adventure

The board gaming world has been abuzz with the whispers of ‘Frosthaven’, the much-anticipated sequel to the iconic ‘Gloomhaven’. As the winter wind blows, it brings with it this new frosty adventure, neatly packed within a box that weighs as much as the expectations it carries. From its inception, ‘Frosthaven’ promised to be more than just a continuation; it vowed to be an evolution, a game that not only took the legacy of its predecessor but also elevated it to uncharted territories.

The initial sticker shock of the game’s price might make some hesitate. After all, with its hefty price tag, ‘Frosthaven’ is undeniably an investment. But delve deeper, and you’ll find that every dollar spent unravels layers of intricately designed gameplay, storytelling, and strategy. As a standalone sequel, it doesn’t merely rest on the laurels of ‘Gloomhaven’; instead, it ventures forth, boldly claiming its own identity. And while the first game set the stage, it’s in ‘Frosthaven’ that the performance truly shines. The challenges are grander, the characters deeper, and the narrative more captivating. Simply put, ‘Frosthaven’ doesn’t just surpass ‘Gloomhaven’—it redefines it.

Unveiling Frosthaven: The Icy Successor to Gloomhaven’s Throne

“Frosthaven” stands tall as the sequel to the legendary board game “Gloomhaven”. But to simply label it as a follow-up would be doing it a disservice. While it carries forward the legacy of its predecessor, it also introduces layers of innovation and enhancement that make it a unique entity in its own right. Much like the frosty landscapes it portrays, “Frosthaven” is a vast, immersive, and deep experience waiting to be explored.

At its core, “Frosthaven” remains true to the dungeon-crawling essence that made “Gloomhaven” a favorite among board gamers. The cooperative spirit is still present, where players use unique decks of cards to orchestrate their moves, working together to complete a plethora of dungeon scenarios. The card-driven combat is as engaging as ever, allowing players to execute a myriad of strategies without the randomness of dice. Every decision becomes crucial, and every card play could mean the difference between victory and defeat.

Yet, where “Frosthaven” truly distinguishes itself is in its expansive character progression and the eponymous outpost of Frosthaven. As players advance in the game, their characters evolve, unlocking new abilities and strategies. This progression isn’t just about stats; it’s a narrative journey, with characters undergoing transformations that impact the story’s direction. The outpost of Frosthaven is another stellar addition, growing and evolving alongside the players. It’s not just a static location but a living entity that responds to the players’ choices, achievements, and even failures.

Comparing “Frosthaven” to “Gloomhaven” is akin to comparing two epic sagas from the same universe. While “Gloomhaven” laid the foundation with its groundbreaking mechanics and storytelling, “Frosthaven” builds upon it, introducing fresh gameplay elements and a richer narrative. From minor tweaks that enhance gameplay quality to major overhauls that reshape the way players approach the game, “Frosthaven” feels like a refined, matured version of its older sibling. In the realm of board games, it’s not just a sequel; it’s a magnum opus.


Check out my DND Backstory Generator made with the latest, greatest AI...

Target Audience: Who’s It For?

Gaming landscapes are vast and varied, and it’s essential to know where you fit in when considering the massive expanse that is Frosthaven. This board game behemoth is no casual Friday night endeavor. Instead, it beckons the most dedicated of board game enthusiasts. But who exactly should be heeding its call?

New Players vs. Gloomhaven Veterans

For those unacquainted with its predecessor, Gloomhaven, stepping into the frigid realms of Frosthaven might feel like trekking through a snowstorm without a coat. The game’s mechanics, while intuitive for seasoned dungeon-crawlers, present a steeper learning curve for newbies. Veterans of Gloomhaven will certainly have an edge, having already mastered the core mechanics, from card-driven combat to the intricacies of scenario progression. However, Frosthaven introduces enough new elements to ensure even the most seasoned Gloomhaven player will find fresh challenges.

Pricing: A Barrier or a Badge of Honor?

When we talk about barriers to entry, we must discuss the icy price tag Frosthaven carries. At a whopping $250, this isn’t a board game you casually pick up on a whim. Newcomers might balk at the price, especially when more affordable introductions to the Gloomhaven universe exist. For instance, ‘Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion’ offers a more condensed experience at a fraction of the price. It serves as a gentler, pocket-friendly introduction to the world and mechanics that creator Isaac Childres has crafted. And with discounts making the original Gloomhaven more accessible, it’s worth considering your options and wallet size before diving into the icy waters of Frosthaven.

Commitment: A Long Haul Adventure

More than money, Frosthaven demands time and dedication. With its expansive content, setting up, playing through scenarios, and managing the outpost can take hours upon hours. Its legacy nature means that the game evolves over time, with decisions having lasting impacts. A full campaign could span months or even years. It’s an immersive experience, akin to diving into a thick fantasy novel where the end is rewarding, but the journey is long and sometimes arduous. For those looking for a deep, engaging board game commitment, Frosthaven awaits. But casual gamers may find the journey more daunting than delightful.

Frosthaven isn’t a one-size-fits-all adventure. It beckons a specific kind of gamer – one ready for commitment, challenges, and, of course, cold. It’s a testament to the fact that, in the world of board games, there truly is something for everyone. But it’s crucial to know where you stand before you step into the snow.

First Impressions: Unboxing & Setup

The anticipation that surrounds unboxing a highly awaited board game is a sensation known well to tabletop enthusiasts. There’s a palpable thrill as you slice through the plastic wrap, revealing the treasure trove of components inside. With Frosthaven, the successor to the acclaimed Gloomhaven, this experience was heightened manifold. The weight of the box promises depth and complexity, setting the stage for a grand adventure ahead.

Fantasy RPG Random Tables Books
Make life as a Gamemaster easier.... If you play Dungeon & Dragons, Pathfinder, or other fantasy tabletop role-playing games, this RPG random tables book is full of encounters, NPCs, and more. Available as an eBook or in a classic print format. Either way, you'll have a wealth of adventure ideas at your fingertips.


Upon first laying hands on the Frosthaven box, the sheer size of it immediately commands attention. Unsealing the lid feels akin to opening a meticulously crafted treasure chest, with layers upon layers of intricately designed components awaiting discovery. While Gloomhaven’s setup was notoriously complex and often overwhelming, it became apparent that Cephalofair Games took player feedback to heart. The components were thoughtfully organized, with storage bags, token containers, and dividers making the process smoother than its predecessor.

The task of punching out cardboard tokens and organizing game pieces, though still a formidable one, now felt less daunting. An entire afternoon might still be dedicated to this endeavor, but the experience was interspersed with moments of delightful surprise as you unearthed the many elements that make up the game.

It wasn’t just the organized setup that set Frosthaven apart. As the game components unfurled, so did the innovations that this sequel brought to the table. The advent-calendar-style boards, allowing players to open little doors and reveal new aspects of their campaign, added a touch of tactile joy. Then there was the rulebook, meticulously crafted with blank spaces awaiting stickers. This design choice hinted at the evolving nature of the game, further enhancing the legacy experience.

Each piece, from the beautifully detailed miniatures to the redesigned character boards, promised deeper immersion and narrative richness. It was clear that Frosthaven wasn’t just building upon the legacy of Gloomhaven but was striving to push the boundaries of what a board game could offer in terms of storytelling and player engagement. The first impressions, simply put, were of awe and eager anticipation for the adventures to come.

Delving Deeper: Classes & Characters

Frosthaven, as the next installment after the widely-celebrated Gloomhaven, ushers in an era of new strategic challenges and narrative depth. At the center of this experience lies the game’s character classes, each meticulously crafted to offer unique playstyles, strategies, and immersive storytelling. Let’s delve deeper into these facets.

Frosthaven’s Class Roster

Frosthaven introduces a fresh lineup of character classes, each deeply interwoven with the icy setting and lore of the land. Classes like the Banner Spear and Blink Blade not only offer distinctive abilities but also reflect the themes and narratives of the frozen wilderness. Beyond mere mechanics, these classes are rich tales waiting to be told, with aesthetics and miniatures enhancing the immersive experience.

Synergy and Strategy

Building on Gloomhaven’s legacy, Frosthaven ups the ante in strategic depth through class combinations. The interplay between classes can either be harmonious or contrasting, opening up myriad strategic avenues. From honing synergies for optimal combat efficiency to crafting unique character narratives, the game encourages players to experiment and customize. Whether it’s through ability upgrades or campaign choices, personalizing one’s character journey becomes an intricate part of the Frosthaven experience.

Embarking on Quests: Scenarios & Dungeons

Diving into Frosthaven, players are immediately struck by the intricate tapestry of scenarios and dungeons awaiting their exploration. These scenarios form the backbone of the Frosthaven experience, serving as the primary medium through which the narrative unfolds and challenges are posed. But how do they stack up against the legacy of Gloomhaven, and what new dimensions do they bring to the table?

Frosthaven’s Scenario Landscape

Each Frosthaven scenario is a blend of storytelling, puzzle-solving, and combat. Whether players find themselves battling through blizzards, navigating treacherous ice caverns, or negotiating with the indigenous tribes of the land, each quest offers a unique set of challenges. The objective variety ensures that no two adventures feel the same. Some might involve rescuing a trapped caravan, while others could see the players defending the outpost from an impending horde. These multifaceted challenges not only test players’ tactical prowess but also immerse them in the rich lore of Frosthaven’s world.

Gloomhaven vs. Frosthaven: Dungeon Dive

Comparing Gloomhaven and Frosthaven side by side reveals both evolutionary and revolutionary changes. While the core mechanics, such as card-driven combat and character progression, remain consistent, Frosthaven introduces fresh gameplay elements and tweaks to enhance the dungeon-crawling experience. One of the standout features is the incorporation of crafting, where players gather resources to create powerful items. This adds an extra layer of strategy, where players must decide between immediate combat gains or long-term crafting benefits. Additionally, Frosthaven feels like a more refined version of its predecessor, with many lessons learned from Gloomhaven finding their way into improved rulesets, scenario designs, and quality of life enhancements.

Is Frosthaven Worth the Investment?

Whenever a sequel or a follow-up to a renowned board game is released, the pressing question among enthusiasts and newcomers alike is simple: is it worth the investment? With Frosthaven, given its lineage and the anticipation surrounding its release, this question takes on even more significance. Let’s dissect Frosthaven’s value proposition and see how it holds up, especially in comparison with its predecessors.

Frosthaven’s Value Proposition

At its core, Frosthaven promises an immersive gameplay experience built on the foundations of Gloomhaven’s tried-and-tested mechanics. It brings a wealth of new content, characters, scenarios, and challenges, not to mention a beautifully detailed world to explore. The incorporation of new gameplay elements, such as crafting and more dynamic scenarios, offers players a refreshed yet familiar experience. This game isn’t just a mere expansion; it’s a stand-alone behemoth that can consume hours upon hours of dedicated gameplay. Additionally, the quality of components, artwork, and narrative depth further enhance its value. When you invest in Frosthaven, you’re not just getting a game; you’re acquiring an extensive, evolving story and countless hours of entertainment.

Comparing with Other Games in the Series

Gloomhaven set a high bar in terms of gameplay depth, component quality, and overall value for money. However, Frosthaven isn’t a mere shadow of its predecessor but an evolution. While Gloomhaven enthusiasts will find a lot of common ground, Frosthaven offers a refreshed setting, more diversified scenarios, and enhanced mechanics. For those who have exhausted Gloomhaven and are hungry for more, Frosthaven feels like a natural next step, offering more of what players loved, with added layers of complexity and innovation. Conversely, for newcomers, Frosthaven can serve as an entry point, though it may be slightly more intimidating given its expansive content.

The Ideal Players for Frosthaven

Frosthaven, with its intricate mechanics and expansive narrative, will undoubtedly resonate with dedicated board gamers who relish depth and strategy. Those who appreciated Gloomhaven will likely find this new installment a worthy successor. Moreover, players who enjoy immersive RPGs, character development, and strategic decision-making will find themselves right at home in the frozen landscapes of Frosthaven. However, casual gamers or those looking for a quick, light game might find Frosthaven a bit daunting given its commitment to depth and duration.

Conclusion: Embracing the Chill of Frosthaven

Frosthaven, with its icy allure, beckons board game enthusiasts to dive deep into its treacherous terrain and vast lore. Having traversed its components, mechanics, scenarios, and value proposition, we are poised to appraise its stature among modern board games and evaluate the legacy it’s building upon.

Fantasy RPG Random Tables Books
Make life as a Gamemaster easier.... If you play Dungeon & Dragons, Pathfinder, or other fantasy tabletop role-playing games, this RPG random tables book is full of encounters, NPCs, and more. Available as an eBook or in a classic print format. Either way, you'll have a wealth of adventure ideas at your fingertips.


Frosthaven’s Appeal and Improvements

Drawing from the rich tapestry that Gloomhaven provided, Frosthaven has artfully built upon the foundation, amplifying its strengths and addressing areas ripe for innovation. The game’s frosty setting not only brings a change in aesthetic but infuses gameplay with unique challenges and dynamics. While the core mechanics remain reminiscent of Gloomhaven, Frosthaven introduces fresh nuances that compel players to strategize differently and reconsider tactics honed in the cobblestoned streets of Gloomhaven. Crafting, dynamic events, and even more intricate character development further solidify Frosthaven’s reputation as a step forward, rather than a mere sidestep.

Frosthaven’s Position in the Board Game Pantheon

In the grand hall of modern board gaming, Frosthaven is quickly establishing its own throne. Whereas Gloomhaven introduced many to the depths and complexities of modern campaign-driven board games, Frosthaven asserts its distinct identity, proving that sequels can be both evolutionary and revolutionary. It’s not just another game; it’s an experience that marries strategy, storytelling, and immersion in a way few others can rival.

The Addictive Nature of Frosthaven

Like a gripping novel that one can’t put down or a TV series that demands binge-watching, Frosthaven ensnares its players. Each session unravels more of the world, beckoning players back to explore, conquer, and evolve. The game doesn’t just demand investment in terms of money but also in time, emotion, and mental energy. And for those willing to embark on this journey, the rewards are manifold. The intricate dance of strategy, the joy of character progression, and the unfolding narrative make it an addictive endeavor.

Embracing Frosthaven is more than just playing a game; it’s about plunging into a world rife with challenges, stories, and strategies. For those willing to brave its icy expanses and invest in its depths, it promises an unparalleled board gaming experience, setting a new gold standard for what this genre can achieve.

Paul Bellow

LitRPG Author Paul Bellow

Paul Bellow is a LitRPG author, gamer, RPG game developer, and publisher of several online communities. In other words, an old school webmaster. He also developed and runs LitRPG Adventures, a set of advanced RPG generators powered by GPT-3 AI. Here at LitRPG Reads, he publishes articles about LitRPG books, tabletop RPG books, and all sorts of DND content that's free to use in your personal tabletop campaign - i.e. non-commercial use. Enjoy your stay and reach out on Twitter or Discord if you want to make contact.

Fantasy RPG Random Tables Books

Make life as a Gamemaster easier....



Or try my D&D Backstory Generator